In The Hindu today, a group of physicians, public-health practitioners and activists working to advance LGBTQIA+ health and rights make a stark argument: the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026, has replaced self-identification with medical certification, and in doing so it has put transgender rights and healthcare at risk.

Parliament passed the Amendment Act earlier this year. It was introduced in the Lok Sabha in March 2026, passed by both Houses within weeks, and came into force on May 25, 2026. The new Act represents a significant shift from the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019.

The 2019 Act recognised a right to self-perceived gender identity. Its Section 4(2) said so in plain terms, and certification by a District Magistrate rested on a self-declaration affidavit under the 2020 Rules. The 2026 amendment deletes Section 4(2). It demands a medical board's recommendation, a selection from prescribed categories, and certification by a District Magistrate. The individual's declaration is replaced by an institutional judgment as the basis of legal recognition.

A definition at odds with medicine

The authors argue that the definition of transgender as introduced in the Amendment Act contradicts established international evidence and the guidelines laid down in the World Health Organization's ICD-11 and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health Standards of Care Version 8.

The new Act also conflates two different issues, they write: whether a person's gender identity is legally valid, and a person's eligibility for social welfare benefits. One is a question of who a person is. The other is a question of what support the state owes them. Tying the two together means a medical board ends up deciding both.

The shift also sits uneasily with the Supreme Court's landmark NALSA judgment of April 15, 2014, which recognised transgender persons as a third gender and held that gender identity is an essential aspect of personal autonomy, dignity and liberty under Article 21. The authors argue the amendment risks undermining those constitutional principles by replacing individual autonomy with medical and bureaucratic control.

No appeal, no review

The new Act does not provide an effective appeal mechanism or independent review, the authors write. That matters because the certificate has implications for access to statutory rights and entitlements. A person refused certification has no clear path to challenge the decision, even as the certificate gates gender-affirming care, documentation, education, insurance and mental health services.

The National Human Rights Commission's 2026 advisory identifies continuing concerns involving education, healthcare, property and inheritance, employment, documentation, and policing and grievance redressal. The Act goes against the NHRC's recommendations, the authors argue, particularly with respect to self-identification, independent grievance mechanisms and reducing documentation barriers.

The health consequences

The authors warn that the Act has many negative public health consequences. Uncertainty about who qualifies has led some providers to delay, suspend or withdraw gender-affirming services. People may turn to unregulated hormones and unqualified providers, raising risks of post-operative complications, infections and side effects.

Transgender persons already hesitate to approach hospitals because of discrimination, fear of judgement, inadequate awareness among healthcare workers, privacy concerns and financial difficulties. Certification requirements, the authors argue, add another barrier to care that should be available to everyone.

Their prescription is simple: transgender healthcare should become part of general healthcare. Transgender persons need all care, primary, preventive, emergency, dental and specialist, not only gender-affirming services. They should not have to search for a transgender-inclusive hospital every time they fall sick.

The authors call on the government to reconsider restrictive definitions, restore self-identification, establish transparent certification and appeal procedures, and ensure uninterrupted access to gender-affirming healthcare. The passage of the 2026 Act, they write, is contributing to a public health emergency. One's humanity should be judged by the people we include rather than by those we exclude.