The Tamil Nadu government on Tuesday asked the Supreme Court to stay a Madras High Court order permitting the traditional Karthigai Deepam lamp to be lit at a stone pillar near a dargah on Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai district, arguing that no custom of lighting the lamp at that spot exists.
A bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul Pancholi heard arguments for more than one and a half hours on Tuesday. The court has not yet decided whether to stay the High Court order, and the hearing will resume on Wednesday at 2 pm.
The state sought urgent relief because Karthigai Deepam falls on November 24 this year, when the lamp would have to be lit at the disputed spot unless the High Court direction is stayed. The respondents are yet to make their submissions, and the bench has not expressed any view on the merits of the case.
The dispute concerns the Deepathoon, a stone lamp pillar situated around 50 metres from the dargah on Thiruparankundram hill. The state says the lamp has traditionally been lit near the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple and not at the pillar close to the dargah.
State says no custom proved at the pillar
Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta, appearing for the state, told the bench that previous Madras High Court judgments had rejected requests to light the lamp at the Deepathoon. He said temple priests had affirmed that, according to the Agamas, the Deepam was traditionally lit near the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple and not at the stone pillar.
Gupta argued that the petitioners had failed to establish a customary right to conduct the ritual at the disputed location. He said a general observation that temple lamps are usually lit on hilltops in Tamil Nadu could not be treated as proof of a specific custom at this spot.
"If the temple says this is the practice, normally the Courts will not interfere," Gupta submitted. He added that the statements of the temple's sthanikars about the traditional lighting of the Deepam near the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple were the relevant evidence of the practice.
Senior Advocate Shekhar Naphade, appearing for the HR and CE Commissioner, also opposed changing the existing arrangement while the matter remained pending. "If some practice has been going on for 100 years, why change it?" he asked.
Status quo urged till the appeal is decided
Naphade argued that the High Court's direction to light the lamp at the hilltop was problematic because the dargah was located at the top of the hill. He said maintaining the status quo would be the reasonable course until the Supreme Court decided the appeal.
Tamil Nadu Additional Advocate General Prashanto Chandra Sen supported these submissions, pointing to earlier High Court decisions rejecting the demand to light the lamp at the Deepathoon. He argued that the latest petition was barred by the principle of res judicata, which prevents the same issue from being litigated again after it has been decided.
Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan also made submissions supporting the state on behalf of the District Collector. Senior Advocate Huzefa Ahmadi, appearing for the Sikandar Badhusah Dargah, briefly argued that the High Court had created a new practice by allowing the ritual at the disputed spot.
How the dispute reached the Supreme Court
The state challenged a January 6 order of a Madras High Court division bench, which upheld a single-judge order passed in December last year allowing the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam at the Deepathoon.
Justice GR Swaminathan had allowed petitions filed by individuals seeking permission to light the lamp at the spot. He held that the ritual would not affect the dargah's rights and that preventing devotees from lighting the lamp would violate their rights.
The state HR and CE Department, which manages the Lord Subramaniya Temple at the foot of the hill, had opposed the petitions, maintaining that the lamp was traditionally lit at another location.
After the state administration refused to permit the ritual, contempt proceedings followed. Justice Swaminathan directed that the lamp lighting be carried out with CISF protection, and the High Court division bench subsequently upheld the orders passed in the contempt proceedings.
In January, the division bench also held that lighting the lamp would not create a law and order problem and that the temple management had a duty to protect its traditions. It rejected the state's contention that the Deepathoon was a survey stone erected by British rulers.
The state had earlier filed a special leave petition in December last year challenging the dismissal of the contempt proceedings, but it was not listed before the Supreme Court. Tuesday's hearing comes ahead of the November 24 festival, and the case will now be heard again on Wednesday afternoon.