Financial influencer Sharan Hegde, known online as Finance with Sharan, has sparked a fierce debate on social media after calling parenthood a 'financial trap' in India. In a post on X on Monday, which has since been deleted, he wrote: "Having a child is a financial trap, and Indians have finally realised it."
Hegde listed the pressures he said young Indians face before they can even think of starting a family. "Can't afford a house. Can't breathe clean air. School fees are ridiculous. Healthcare is expensive. Job security is disappearing," he wrote. "And after all that, you are expected to raise a child and save enough for your own retirement."
He linked the argument to India's falling fertility rate. In his post, he said Kerala and Tamil Nadu have fertility rates of 1.3 children per woman, while India's overall fertility rate has fallen to 1.9, below the replacement level of 2.1. He ended the post by asking: "Who can even afford to have a child in this economy?"
The post was widely shared and quoted before it was deleted, and the argument it made has divided opinion sharply. Many users pushed back hard, saying parenthood cannot be reduced to a financial calculation.
Critics call it a blessing, not a trap
"Having a child is not a financial trap. It is a blessing. Life is much more than just a financial calculator," one user wrote. Another said: "Disagree. Happiness of having a baby is greater than having a lot of money. Many of my friends, some even promoters of unlisted companies, 40-plus now are struggling to have a kid. They have tons of money but the smile has disappeared from their faces."
A third response drew a line between cost and value: "This is such a simplistic way of looking at life. There is a difference between saying raising a child is expensive and calling a child a financial trap. Having a child was never meant to be purely a financial decision. Sadly, we are turning it into one. Life isn't finance. We have just made it one."
Others were blunter. "What a pathetic way to look at life," one user wrote. "Reducing the entire experience of parenthood to a financial calculation is so shallow. You will definitely revisit this tweet once you enter parenthood. If money is the only measure of a meaningful life, you have already missed the point of living."
Supporters say he is not wrong
Not everyone disagreed. "He might get a lot of hate for this but he isn't wrong. No kids or 1 kid would become the norm in middle class families soon," one user wrote. Another agreed that parenthood could become a marker of wealth, writing: "Having a child is the next status symbol of the ultra rich in the 2040s. It's already happening."
One supporter pointed to the wider economy, arguing that the world has changed and that Hegde was only stating data. Another noted the irony that people with money are choosing not to have children while people without money are having three or four.
The debate also widened into a broader argument about the cost of living and India's demographic future. Some users pointed out that falling birth rates are not unique to India and that countries across income groups have seen similar changes, with rising incomes and falling fertility often going hand in hand. Others raised concerns about India's broader economic outlook, arguing that growing financial pressures could push talented young Indians to their limits.
News18, which first reported the row, noted that its article was based on user-generated content and that the claims in the original post had not been independently verified. The fertility figures in this article are those cited by Hegde in his post.