About Rs 15,000 crore flowed into Indian equities after the US midterm election results, but that sudden infusion should not hide a more fundamental question, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor argues in an op-ed in The Hindu. The question, as he puts it, is whether India's investment policy environment has become increasingly difficult for global capital to navigate, and whether that is hurting the economy.
Tharoor's central argument is that predictability, not the level of tax rates, drives investor confidence. Tax rates matter, he writes, but what investors weigh most is whether policy is predictable, consistent and competitive. On that test, he argues, India is failing.
The numbers he cites are striking. Over two years, South Korea's KOSPI rose 160 per cent, Pakistan's KSE-100 rose 107 per cent, Taiwan's TAIEX rose 105 per cent, Japan's Nikkei-225 rose 70 per cent, Germany's DAX rose 30 per cent and Britain's FTSE100 rose 26 per cent, while India's Nifty 50 fell 14 per cent. Tharoor is careful to say that this weakness is the cumulative outcome of several causes, taxation, regulatory uncertainty, liquidity constraints, the cost of capital, corporate earnings pressures and the volatile priorities of international investors, and that tax is only one of them.
A tax history that keeps changing
The op-ed traces the shifting treatment of capital gains on listed shares. Before October 2004, long-term capital gains on listed shares were generally taxed at 20 per cent with indexation, or 10 per cent without, whichever was lower. In 2004, long-term gains were exempted under Section 10(38) and the securities transaction tax was introduced, with short-term gains taxed at a concessional 10 per cent under Section 111A.
In 2018, the exemption on long-term gains was withdrawn and a 10 per cent tax reintroduced, while the transaction tax stayed in place. In July 2024, the government raised the long-term rate from 10 per cent to 12.5 per cent and the short-term rate from 15 per cent to 20 per cent. The 2026 Union Budget raised the transaction tax again, this time on futures and options.
Tharoor argues that the simultaneous imposition of capital gains tax and transaction tax raises legitimate concerns about the cumulative burden, particularly in periods when markets are weak. The deeper complaint is about direction: an investor who entered the market under one set of rules has watched those rules change four times in eight years.
The retrospective tax shadow
The op-ed returns to the 2012 retrospective tax amendment, which Tharoor presents as the original wound to India's reputation for predictability. The Finance Act of 2012 amended Section 9 of the Income-tax Act with retrospective effect, undoing the Supreme Court's judgment in favour of Vodafone in the Hutchison Essar deal, and led to years of international arbitration involving Vodafone and Cairn Energy.
The retrospective provision was repealed by the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act of 2021, introduced on 5 August 2021 and assented to on 13 August 2021, with a cut-off date of 28 May 2012. Tharoor argues that the reputational damage lingered well beyond the repeal. He also cites the 2018 Flipkart-Walmart tax dispute as a further blow to perceptions of predictability.
More recently, with foreign investors pulling money out and the rupee under pressure, the Income-tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026, gazetted on 5 June 2026, removed tax on foreign portfolio investors' gains from Government Securities, through entries 13D and 13E in Schedule IV of the Income-tax Act, 2025. But the exemption does not cover equity, and long-term capital gains on foreign investors' equity holdings stay at 12.5 per cent.
Tharoor posted on X on Tuesday flagging the article, crediting research shared by his Thiruvananthapuram colleague Shibu Appukuttan, and urging Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman to take note. With the next Union Budget and Finance Bill on the horizon, his argument is that the government should use the moment to make the tax regime stable enough that investors can plan around it, rather than in spite of it.