In an editorial published on Tuesday, The Hindu BusinessLine argues that the Securities and Exchange Board of India should not categorise inactive demat accounts as dormant. What follows is the editorial's argument.
It is perplexing, the editorial says, that SEBI should consider categorising inactive demat accounts, those which do not record any client-led transaction for two years, as dormant. The proposed move, reported by the newspaper recently, seems to be along the lines of the Reserve Bank of India labelling idle accounts as inactive. But demat and bank accounts are very different indeed.
While inactive banks' savings and current accounts may turn out to be dummies or "mules" to be used by fraudsters, this cannot be said for demat accounts, the editorial argues. The comparison with bank accounts does not hold, and the regulator's worry is misplaced.
Inactive does not mean abandoned
Inactive demat accounts are quite common, especially with long-term investors, those who hold assets for more than two years. Their demat accounts will not see much churn. Labelling these as dormant will merely hassle investors and increase their compliance burden, the editorial says.
SEBI appears to have been concerned by the unusual increase in inactive accounts. The number of demat accounts has surged since the Covid-19 pandemic, when many new investors entered the market, to currently stand at over 24 crore. The share of inactive accounts, defined by SEBI as an account where no transaction has taken place for a continuous period of 12 months, stands at 71 per cent of the total demat accounts in NSDL and 67 per cent in CDSL.
But this increase could be on account of two factors, the editorial argues. One, investors are opening multiple demat accounts at the behest of their brokers. A SEBI study found that discount brokers, in particular, have been asking clients to open new demat accounts to trade with them. This would have led to no transactions in older accounts.
Unlisted shares explain much of the inactivity
Two, with the number of start-ups growing and issuing shares, the need for demat accounts to hold these shares has also increased. While NSDL held 1.06 lakh crore listed shares, it held 2.75 lakh crore unlisted shares. Investors who open demat accounts for holding unlisted shares are unlikely to churn their portfolios.
However, access to such accounts is limited to the depository participants, stockbrokers and central depositories. Individual investors will find it hard to access these accounts or execute transactions through them. To allay its fears of fraud, the editorial says, SEBI can ask all DPs to provide a monthly report on the inactive accounts held with them for over two years, along with any sudden activity.
If investors are mandated to execute some transaction every year, just to keep the accounts active, they may be forced to buy or sell stocks, which may lead to loss and additional outgo on tax and brokerage. That would punish exactly the patient, long-term investors the market should encourage.
A simpler alternative
Instead of categorising accounts as dormant and mandating some long-winded procedure to regularise them, SEBI can ask the central depositories to send annual mails to all demat account holders requiring them to fill a simple form stating that they continue to use the demat account, the editorial proposes.
If there is no reply from owners of a demat account which have been inactive for over five years and hold no securities, the closure of such accounts can be considered. That, the editorial argues, would deal with genuinely dead accounts without putting crores of ordinary investors through needless anxiety.