The Supreme Court will on Wednesday hear a plea by the Supreme Court Bar Association seeking criminal contempt action against a lawyer who allegedly made unsavoury remarks against Chief Justice of India Surya Kant during court proceedings on Monday.
The Bar Association filed the criminal contempt petition on Tuesday, a day after advocate Pravin Singhal allegedly made the remarks in open court. The petition seeks action against him for allegedly scandalising the judiciary.
The petition was filed after Attorney General R Venkataramani granted his consent to initiate criminal contempt proceedings against the advocate over the alleged scandalous remarks made against the Chief Justice.
In a letter dated November 17, Venkataramani informed Supreme Court Bar Association Secretary Pragya Baghel that he had granted consent to initiate criminal contempt proceedings against Singhal for his "extremely scandalous and unpardonable" remarks against CJI Kant.
Mentioned for urgent listing on Tuesday
The Supreme Court on Tuesday agreed to take up the matter on November 18 after Baghel and Joint Secretary Meenesh Dubey mentioned it for urgent listing before a bench comprising CJI Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana.
Singhal allegedly made personal remarks against CJI Kant on Monday while seeking an urgent hearing in a case related to allegations of corruption in the judiciary.
He told the court that he had submitted papers to the Chief Justice's office on November 2 but had received no response. When CJI Kant asked him to wait, Singhal allegedly refused and questioned the Chief Justice's suitability to hold the office.
Singhal was subsequently escorted out of the courtroom by security personnel, in an unusual courtroom episode that drew attention across the legal fraternity.
Consent of the Attorney General
Under the Contempt of Courts Act, a private party needs the written consent of the Attorney General before moving the Supreme Court for criminal contempt. The requirement acts as a filter, so that contempt proceedings are started only where the law officer is satisfied that the case warrants the court's attention.
The Attorney General's consent in this case came on the same day the Bar Association moved the court, and the matter was listed for hearing the next day.
Baghel and Dubey also sought permission to club the proposed contempt proceedings against Singhal with the pending contempt case against Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle.
What happens next
The bench will on Wednesday consider the Bar Association's plea and decide how the contempt proceedings should move forward. No finding has been made against Singhal so far, and the allegations against him remain to be tested in the proceedings.
The episode has once again brought the debate over courtroom conduct and the limits of criticism of judges into focus, with the Bar Association taking the position that remarks made in open court crossed the line into scandalising the judiciary.