The Bombay High Court on Wednesday quashed the sanction granted by ICICI Bank to the Central Bureau of Investigation to prosecute its former chief executive officer and managing director Chanda Kochhar in the alleged ICICI Bank-Videocon loan fraud case.
A single-judge bench of Justice Milind N Jadhav held that the sanction order dated May 15, 2023 was illegal and deserved to be set aside, on the ground that the authority which granted it was not the competent authority and had completely failed to apply its mind to the material placed before it.
"In view of the findings and observations, it is writ large on the face of record that the impugned sanction dated May 15, 2023 is illegal and deserves to be set aside on the ground that the authority that granted the same is not a competent authority and it completely failed to apply its mind to the material, or lack thereof, placed before it while granting sanction, thereby warranting interference of this Court," Justice Jadhav noted while pronouncing the order.
The bench held the sanction order to be unsustainable in law, being a nullity, and quashed and set it aside. The court also declined a request by CBI lawyer Kuldeep Patil to stay the ruling for eight weeks so the agency could challenge its legality and validity.
Kochhar had challenged the sanction through senior advocate Amit Desai, who argued that the bank did not follow proper procedure while granting sanction to prosecute its former CEO and MD, and that the sanction therefore required to be quashed. Desai also argued that the bank's decision was inconsistent with its earlier position that it had suffered no financial loss on account of the loans disbursed to the Videocon Group between June 2009 and October 2011.
The loans at the centre of the case
The CBI's case relates to alleged violations in the sanctioning of six loans aggregating approximately Rs 1,575 crore to five companies belonging to the Videocon Group between 2009 and 2011.
The agency registered an FIR in 2019 naming Chanda Kochhar, her husband Deepak Kochhar, Videocon Group founder Venugopal Dhoot, and companies including Nupower Renewables, Supreme Energy, Videocon International Electronics and Videocon Industries. The CBI has alleged that ICICI Bank sanctioned credit facilities of about Rs 3,250 crore to these companies in violation of banking norms, RBI guidelines and the bank's own credit policy.
The investigation began in 2018 after allegations emerged that Dhoot had transferred money to a company allegedly established by him along with Deepak Kochhar and two of his relatives, months after the loans were sanctioned.
Arrest, bail and the sanction
The CBI arrested Chanda Kochhar and her husband on December 23, 2022. The Bombay High Court granted them interim bail on January 9, 2023, and later held that their arrest was illegal.
The ICICI Bank board passed a resolution on April 22, 2023 granting sanction for Kochhar's prosecution, and the sanction order itself was issued on May 15, 2023. Kochhar challenged that sanction in the High Court, arguing that the procedure for granting it had not been properly followed.
With the sanction now quashed, the prosecution founded on it cannot proceed unless the order is challenged and overturned. A detailed copy of the court's order is awaited.