Yes Bank has filed a review petition in the Supreme Court seeking a reconsideration of the ruling that set aside the Rs 8,400 crore write-off of its additional tier-1 (AT-1) bonds, The Week reported on Saturday. The bank is challenging a judgment that went against it after the Bombay High Court had first quashed the write-off and the Supreme Court upheld that decision in October.

The review petition comes as Axis Trustee Services, acting on behalf of bondholders, has filed a contempt petition in the Supreme Court alleging that Yes Bank has failed to implement the judgment. The trustee has accused the bank of failing to provide a definitive roadmap to restore the bonds, according to the report.

AT-1 bonds are debt instruments that offer high returns but carry greater risk, because they can be written off or converted into equity when a lender comes under financial pressure. The write-off at the centre of this dispute was part of the restructuring scheme put in place when Yes Bank was rescued and new investors were brought in.

The dispute traces back to the bank's reconstruction, when Japan's Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corp, which held a 24 per cent stake in Yes Bank, was declared insolvent six years ago. When new investors were brought in under the restructuring scheme, the AT-1 bonds were written off, according to Reuters.

The courts took a different view of that write-off. The Bombay High Court set it aside, and the Supreme Court upheld the High Court's ruling in October, holding that the write-off was impermissible.

What the court found wrong with the write-off


The Supreme Court held that the Yes Bank administrator had given an erroneous impression that he held the authority to write down the bonds after the restructuring scheme was finalised. The court ruled that the write-off could not stand on that basis.

The judgment meant the bonds, worth Rs 84 billion, had to be restored, a liability the bank is now contesting through its review petition. A review petition asks the same court to reconsider its own judgment, and it is decided on narrow grounds.

The contempt petition filed by Axis Trustee Services adds pressure on the bank from the other side. Bondholders, through the trustee, are asking the court to hold the bank accountable for what they describe as a failure to carry out the judgment.

The two petitions pull in opposite directions. The bank wants the ruling revisited, while the bondholders want it enforced without further delay.

Why the case matters beyond Yes Bank


The outcome will be watched across the banking sector because AT-1 bonds are a widely used instrument for raising capital. The ruling affects how banks and investors understand the risks attached to these bonds in a restructuring.

For bondholders, the case is about whether the write-off of their investments during a bank rescue can be undone by the courts. For the bank, the review petition is the remaining legal route to challenge a judgment that restored a liability of Rs 8,400 crore.

The Supreme Court will now have to decide whether to admit the review petition and, separately, how to deal with the contempt petition alleging non-implementation of its judgment. No date for hearing either petition has been reported yet.