The court also ruled that a divorce granted on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage cannot automatically be recognised in India when the marriage was solemnised under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The observations were made while the bench was hearing a case involving allegations of bigamy and criminal conspiracy.
The court refused to cancel the criminal proceedings against a man who relied on a divorce decree from the United Kingdom before marrying another woman. It explained that foreign divorce judgments must satisfy Indian legal requirements before they can be accepted by Indian courts, and that a foreign court cannot automatically decide the legal status of a marriage solemnised under Indian law.
The case involved a man who married his first wife on 18 April 2003 in Sattenapalli, Andhra Pradesh, according to Hindu customs and traditions. The couple later moved to the United Kingdom, where the husband pursued his medical career.
How the dispute reached the Supreme Court
The relationship between the couple eventually faced difficulties, and the husband initially approached an Indian court for divorce and child custody proceedings. Those proceedings were dismissed, and he later withdrew his appeal before the Andhra Pradesh High Court.
The husband acquired British citizenship on 1 February 2013. After that, he approached the Cambridge County Court in England for a divorce, which the UK court granted in 2014 on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage.
He subsequently married another woman in Norfolk in the United Kingdom. His first wife later filed a police complaint in India alleging bigamy and criminal conspiracy, raising the question whether the first marriage was still legally valid under Indian law despite the foreign divorce decree.
The Supreme Court refused to quash the criminal proceedings against the husband. However, it set aside the proceedings against his parents and his second wife. The court clarified that the question of bigamy cannot be examined only by looking at where the second marriage took place, and that Indian courts must also consider whether the first marriage was legally dissolved under the applicable Indian law.
What Section 13 of the CPC requires
Section 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure sets out when a foreign court judgment can be recognised in India. A foreign judgment may not be considered conclusive if it was passed by a court without proper legal jurisdiction, was not decided on the merits, refused to recognise Indian law when Indian law applied, violated the principles of natural justice, was obtained through fraud, or supported a claim that violated Indian law.
The Supreme Court explained that foreign matrimonial judgments must satisfy these legal conditions before they can receive recognition in India. Obtaining a divorce from a foreign court does not automatically give someone the right to remarry under Indian law.
If the foreign divorce decree is not legally recognised in India, the first marriage may continue to be treated as valid under Indian law. In such circumstances, a second marriage could lead to allegations of bigamy.
The court also rejected the argument that obtaining foreign citizenship could protect the husband from legal consequences. It explained that a change in nationality does not automatically remove the legal consequences of a marriage originally solemnised under Indian law.