The bench found that the original hakku patra, the provisional title deed dated 5 January 1972, stood in Balakrishna's favour. The rival claimant, G N Kanniah Naidu, had never produced the original grant document, relying instead on a photocopy. The court held that the decree Naidu obtained against Srikanta Rao was liable to be nullified.
"The claim to title and ownership by Balakrishna stood settled in his favour by the original hakku patra dated 05.01.1972," Justice Kumar wrote for the bench. Naidu had claimed that the Tahsildar had taken the original grant back because of multiple allotments and never returned it, but Balakrishna's side placed the original document on record.
The dispute began with a suit filed in 1987, and an objection in execution proceedings followed in 2002. The executing court dismissed the objection in September 2008, and the Karnataka High Court affirmed that dismissal in August 2011. The Supreme Court has now set aside both the High Court judgment and the executing court's order, along with the underlying decree of 8 October 1999.
The site now falls within Bengaluru East Taluk. The judgment brings to an end a dispute that has run for more than five decades since the original government allotment.
Lower courts showed total non-application of mind
The Supreme Court was sharply critical of how the lower courts had handled the case. The executing court had faulted Balakrishna's son Ananda for lacking personal knowledge of the 1972 grant, ignoring that his father had authorised him through a power of attorney and that the original hakku patra itself had been exhibited.
The High Court, in turn, had held that an application under Order XXI Rules 97 to 101 of the Code of Civil Procedure could not raise questions of title, and that the objector should have filed a separate suit. The Supreme Court said both observations reflected total non-application of mind to the statutory scheme.
An application under those rules is on par with a regular suit, the bench explained, which is why an order passed on such an application is appealable as a regular first appeal. Order XXI Rule 101 expressly bars a separate suit, the bench reminded the High Court.
The court also held that sporadic tax receipts produced by both sides were irrelevant to the question of title once the original grant document was before the court. Tax receipts cannot settle title, the bench held.
Naidu's own admissions proved fatal to his claim
The bench placed weight on Naidu's own admissions during cross-examination in the execution proceedings. He conceded that Balakrishna had constructed a ground-plus-first-floor RCC house with three shops on the front portion of the site and had leased those shops to tenants.
"This admission on his part was fatal to his claim that it was Srikanta Rao, who trespassed upon the site and built a hut there," Justice Kumar recorded. No explanation was offered as to how Balakrishna came into possession and raised permanent structures without any challenge from Naidu for years.
When the Supreme Court called upon the Tahsildar's office in 2022, the office could not trace the 1972 records but voiced no doubt about the authenticity of the original hakku patra issued to Balakrishna. That position supported the bench's conclusion that the original deed settled the question of title.