The Madras High Court on Tuesday struck down a Tamil Nadu government rule that empowered authorities to ban the transportation of rough stone and other minerals from the state to neighbouring states.
A First Division Bench of Chief Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari and Justice G. Arul Murugan declared Rule 3-A of the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Illegal Mining, Transportation and Storage of Minerals and Mineral Dealers' Rules, 2011 unconstitutional and beyond the powers of the central mining law.
The bench also quashed a July 27 order of the Director of Geology and Mining imposing a three-month ban on transporting rough stone and aggregates outside Tamil Nadu, except to Puducherry and the Karaikal region.
What Rule 3-A allowed
Rule 3-A was inserted into the 2011 Rules through an amendment notified on July 9, 2026. It empowered the Director of Geology and Mining to regulate the transportation of rough stone, boulders, M-sand, metal jelly and other construction materials to other states, including by imposing temporary bans to ensure adequate supply within Tamil Nadu.
The rule covered rough stones including khandas, boulders and crushed materials, along with manufactured sand, metal jelly, ballast, mill stones, hand chakais and building and road construction stones.
Acting under the rule, the Director imposed a three-month ban on July 27. The ban was later extended by another three months from October 27.
Mining leaseholders, stone crusher operators and quarry owners' associations challenged the rule in a batch of writ petitions before the principal seat of the High Court in Chennai and its Madurai Bench.
The court's reasoning
The bench held that Section 23-C of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, under which the state framed the rule, is intended exclusively to prevent illegal mining, transportation and storage. It does not authorise the state to restrict the movement of minerals lawfully excavated under valid leases after royalty has been paid.
Once minerals are lawfully excavated, ownership vests entirely with the lessee, the court observed. "Once the State has permitted mining and allowed the excavation of minerals, imposing a temporary ban on their transport to other States has no rationale or reasonable nexus with the object that is sought to be achieved," the bench said.
The judges also held that the restriction violated Part XIII of the Constitution, particularly Article 301, which guarantees freedom of trade, commerce and intercourse throughout the territory of India. The petitioners had also argued that the rule was beyond the scope of Section 23-C(1) of the MMDR Act.
The bench relied on the Supreme Court's 2019 judgment in State of Gujarat v. Jayeshbhai Kanjibhai Kalathiya, which had held that state governments could not prohibit the inter-state transportation or sale of lawfully mined minerals by framing rules under the MMDR Act.
State's defence rejected
The state defended the rule, arguing that the restriction was needed to balance domestic demand, public safety and the availability of construction materials. It said excessive inter-state transportation had resulted in minerals being diverted predominantly to Middle Eastern countries.
The government also argued that the three-month ban had effectively run its course, making the challenge largely infructuous. The court rejected these arguments.
The bench clarified that the state can still regulate mining at the stage of granting leases, and can impose reasonable measures on maximum vehicle loads, speed and public safety. It can also invoke Section 4-A of the MMDR Act, which allows premature termination of mining leases on specified grounds including environmental protection and public safety.
Allowing all the writ petitions, the court ordered that there would be no order as to costs.