The writ petition challenged a Movement Restriction Order issued by the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO) under Section 7(2)(f) of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, and Paragraph 8 of the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025. The order required the affected individual to remain at a designated holding facility until repatriation.
The authorities treated the individual as a suspected Bangladeshi national. The individual, however, asserted Indian citizenship by birth and relied on several identity and residence-related records, including a passport, voter identity card, Aadhaar card, PAN card, driving licence, business registrations, GST registration and municipal identity documentation.
The authorities disputed the reliability of certain foundational records, particularly the birth certificate and a death certificate. They also relied on an earlier criminal conviction under the Foreigners Act, 1946, which remained under appeal. The individual had been released on bail during the pendency of that appeal.
A serious dispute cannot be resolved by assumption
The central question before the court was not whether the person was ultimately an Indian citizen or a foreign national. Instead, the court considered whether the movement restriction and proposed repatriation could continue when the citizenship claim had not been determined through an adequate legal process.
The court found that a serious dispute over nationality cannot be resolved merely by administrative assumption, particularly where the affected person has consistently claimed Indian citizenship and has produced multiple official records.
The judgment draws a distinction between rights reserved for citizens and constitutional protections available to every person. Article 19 rights, such as free movement and settlement throughout India, are limited to citizens. However, Articles 14 and 21 apply to all persons within India, including foreigners and persons whose citizenship status is under inquiry.
This means that even where the State suspects a person to be a foreign national, any process that may restrict liberty, lead to confinement, or result in removal from India must meet standards of fairness, reasonableness and non-arbitrariness.
Movement restrictions need due process
The court recognised that Section 7(2)(f)(ii) of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, permits authorities to require a foreigner to reside at a particular place and to impose movement-related restrictions. It did not hold that the statutory power to issue a movement restriction order was inherently invalid, but said the power must be exercised consistently with constitutional safeguards and the statutory framework.
In this case, the court noted that the order did not meaningfully assess the records relied upon by the affected individual. The subsequent verification and evaluation of those materials took place during the writ proceedings, rather than before the restrictive order was made. That sequence was material, the court said, because a post-order inquiry could not cure the failure to provide a fair opportunity before reaching a conclusion that the person was a foreign national.
Paragraph 16 of the Foreigners Order, 2025, provides for referral of the question of whether a person is a foreigner to a Foreigners Tribunal. The court observed that the determination of nationality should be undertaken through the legally prescribed process, especially where the person disputes foreign-national status and produces documents supporting citizenship.
The burden of proving that a person is not a foreigner may lie on the person concerned under Section 16 of the 2025 Act. Yet the court emphasised that this burden does not remove the State's obligation to ensure a fair, lawful and reasoned determination.
The court also examined government guidelines on identifying and deporting persons alleged to be illegal Bangladeshi nationals or Rohingya nationals. Where a suspected person claims Indian citizenship and identifies a place of residence in India, the guidelines require verification from the relevant State or district authorities. The court found that the required process had not been completed before the movement restriction order was issued, and that the verification exercise was initiated only after the writ petition had been filed.
The High Court disposed of the writ petition with directions that the authorities take further steps in accordance with law, provide the affected individual an adequate opportunity to present the citizenship claim, and undertake the required determination expeditiously. Until that process is completed, the court directed that repatriation or deportation must not be carried out.