The Karnataka High Court has quashed income tax reassessment proceedings over the purchase of immovable property worth approximately Rs 60 lakh, holding that the final assessment of only Rs 10 lakh fell below the statutory threshold for reassessment after three years under Section 149 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Justice B. M. Shyam Prasad allowed both writ petitions filed by the petitioner, TaxScan reported on Saturday.

Manjula Narayana Reddy, the petitioner, had jointly purchased immovable property with her son through a sale deed dated 24 March 2016. The Income Tax Department initiated reassessment proceedings for Assessment Year 2016-17 on the ground that she had not filed income tax returns despite purchasing the property.

The petitioner received a notice under Section 148 on 19 March 2023, followed by a notice under Section 142(1) on 10 October 2023. Although she responded to the latter notice, she did not respond to subsequent notices or the intimation under Section 144B.

The petitioner's counsel argued that she was a homemaker and had joined her son in purchasing the property only because he wanted her to be a co-owner for emotional reasons. She explained that she did not have a bank account until 2021 and that her son had obtained a Rs 50 lakh loan based on his salary, which was directly paid to the seller.

Only Rs 10 lakh was actually assessed


The remaining Rs 10 lakh was claimed to have come from family savings, but the petitioner had not produced sufficient supporting documents during the assessment proceedings. The Assessing Officer accepted the explanation concerning the Rs 50 lakh loan but completed the assessment on 12 March 2024 in respect of Rs 10 lakh.

The petitioner subsequently filed an appeal with a delay of 189 days, citing ill-health. The appellate authority rejected the appeal on 7 August 2025, observing that she had incorrectly marked "NO" in Form 35 against the question concerning delay.

Justice Shyam Prasad observed that the best judgment assessment under Section 144 read with Section 144B and Section 147 of the Act was not for the entire Rs 60 lakh initially alleged to be income chargeable to tax that had escaped assessment, but only for Rs 10 lakh.

"This would be far below the threshold which would permit reassessment under Section 147 of the Act after the lapse of 3 years from the end of the relevant assessment," the court observed.

The court also considered the joint bank account statement and details of payments towards the remaining Rs 10 lakh, including Rs 60,000 towards TDS and cheques totalling Rs 9.40 lakh. It allowed both writ petitions and quashed the assessment proceedings.

Why the threshold matters


Section 149 of the Income Tax Act sets a monetary limit on the department's power to reopen old assessments. After three years from the end of the relevant assessment year, reassessment is permitted only where the income that escaped assessment meets the statutory threshold.

The judgment turns on a practical point: the threshold is tested against the amount actually assessed as escaped income, not the larger figure initially alleged when the proceedings began. Here, the department's own assessment settled at Rs 10 lakh, well below the limit.

The ruling will matter for taxpayers facing reassessment notices for older years, particularly where the department's final addition is far smaller than the amount flagged at the notice stage. It also underlines that the department must test its jurisdiction against the assessed figure before proceeding.