An 18-second video purportedly showing CRPF Special Director General Sandeep Khirwar defending the transport of two slain Special Police Officers' bodies in a dumper truck is AI manipulated, a fact check by NewsMeter has found.

The clip, which carries a news agency logo, has been circulating on social media with claims that Khirwar said the families of the two SPOs should be grateful that they received the bodies of their loved ones at all.

In the fabricated clip, the officer is purportedly heard saying, "All military trucks and vehicles in the area were occupied. So we had no choice but to transport the bodies of our two martyred SPO personnel in a dumper truck. But the real issue is not whether they were transported in a dumper or a garbage truck. Their families received the bodies of their loved ones. What more could they possibly want?"

Those words were never spoken by Khirwar. The fact check found that the viral video was created by manipulating genuine footage of the officer with an AI-generated audio track.

Same footage, different words

NewsMeter traced the clip to an original 28-second video of Khirwar speaking to the media in Srinagar on November 16, recorded against the exact same background.

A close comparison found that the viral video and the original have the same head movements and turns, and even the people in the background move in the same way. Only Khirwar's lip movements and the audio are different, indicating that the viral video's audio track is not authentic.

Two AI detection tools confirmed the manipulation. An analysis using Hiya Audio Intelligence found a very low probability of the audio track being real, stating, "This voice seems generated or modified by AI. There is only a 3% match with live human markers."

Another tool, Hive Moderation, determined that the video is 98.8 per cent likely to contain AI generated speech.

What Khirwar actually said

In the original video, Khirwar said nothing about the transportation of the bodies in a dumper. His remarks were an expression of solidarity with the bereaved families and an assurance of justice.

"All I can say is that every loss of life to any jawan in the security forces is a huge loss to all of us, and we owe our utmost respect to all the fallen. We stand with their families. We will make sure that they get justice, their families get justice," he said.

The fabricated clip was shared widely, including by accounts claiming that the bodies were transported in a garbage truck after the Army refused to provide an ambulance, and that the families should be grateful. Those claims about the officer's remarks are false.

The deaths behind the outrage

The doctored clip spread against the backdrop of genuine anger and grief in Kishtwar following the deaths of SPOs Rashpal Kumar, 45, and Bobby Chand, 57, both residents of Kiyar Dachhan who were serving with the Special Operations Group in the Kiyar sector.

Both went missing on November 10 while travelling to an Army post at Dharna-Marwah for rotation duty. Their bullet-riddled bodies were recovered from a remote forest area near a nullah in Kishtwar district on November 12, and their service rifles were reported missing.

Their bodies were reportedly brought to their native Kiyar village in a dumper, without a coffin, triggering outrage in the area. Locals said no senior police officer accompanied the bodies.

Kishtwar BJP MLA Shagun Parihar questioned the manner in which the bodies were transported and demanded accountability from the authorities. "You brought the bodies of our people here in a dumper truck. Is this the value of our jawans?" she asked while confronting police personnel, also questioning the absence of senior officers when the families were seeking answers.