Union Minister of State for Petroleum and Natural Gas Suresh Gopi on Tuesday dismissed allegations that the ethanol content in petrol supplied by oil marketing companies had exceeded the prescribed 20 per cent limit, calling those making such claims "idiots who do not know science".

Speaking at the 'Youth Dialogue with SG' programme in his parliamentary constituency of Thrissur, Gopi said the controversy was politically motivated and accused those raising concerns of not understanding the science behind ethanol blending.

"These fools don't know the science behind it. Some malicious political forces are exploiting the E20 issue for political gains," he said.

"I will not call such persons any bad names. All I would say is that none of these idiots have any knowledge about science," he added.

The row over ethanol levels

The controversy erupted after the Kerala and Karnataka state governments claimed that independent laboratory tests had detected ethanol levels exceeding 31 per cent at certain fuel stations, far above the permissible limit of 20 per cent.

The Congress-ruled Karnataka government has alleged that the ethanol content in petrol is higher than the permitted limit, while Keralam has been conducting tests to examine whether the ethanol content in petrol was exceeding the prescribed limit.

Gopi fiercely defended the Centre's ethanol-blending policy, saying the transition from E10 to E20 fuel was implemented only after extensive scientific evaluation and clearance by the Automotive Research Association of India (ARAI).

He said India had moved from E10 to E20 ethanol blending after extensive "scientific research and re-research" and approval from ARAI, and that ethanol blending was the only option to reduce pollution from petrol-powered vehicles.

'No possibility of exceeding 20 per cent'

Explaining the blending process, Gopi said ethanol-blending machines were calibrated to ensure a 20 per cent mix and that there was no possibility of ethanol content exceeding that limit in India.

He maintained that the scientifically approved blending limit was 20 per cent and that this was the maximum ethanol content consumers would get from any retail fuel outlet.

He claimed that no registered complaints related to the use of E20 petrol had been received and that no insurance company had received claims on the issue.

Citing Brazil as an example, he said that country used E80 fuel rather than E20, and that ethanol blending was a proven path to cutting vehicle emissions.

Gopi questions the samples, seeks CBI probe

Referring to state laboratory reports that allegedly detected unusually high levels of ethanol, Gopi sarcastically questioned the integrity of the samples collected for testing.

"I don't know if some 'great people' collected the samples in a jerrycan and mixed them themselves," he said, implying possible localised fuel tampering, adulteration or political mischief.

He alleged that those making such claims and testing ethanol content in fuel may have bought petrol in canisters and mixed something in it before taking samples.

Gopi said that if illegal blending or systematic adulteration was indeed taking place at specific retail outlets, the matter warranted a thorough investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). He added that it would have to be ascertained through a CBI probe whether any adulteration had taken place and whether samples had been collected from outlets where such practices were suspected.

He also took a swipe at his critics, remarking that those demanding answers would be the first to complain if central agencies intervened in the investigation.

'Anyone is free to test'

Gopi said anyone was free to test the ethanol content in petrol and that he would not discourage such checks.

He alleged that several "evil" political claims were being made about ethanol blending, particularly allegations that the permitted limit had been exceeded.

The minister's remarks come amid a raging debate over E20 fuel, with state governments, motorists and opposition parties raising questions about fuel quality, vehicle compatibility and the transparency of the blending process, while the Centre insists the programme is scientifically sound.