India exempted an Israeli phone-hacking company from its own procurement rules, clearing the way for government agencies to buy phone-extraction products and surveillance technology, an investigation by the digital-rights group Internet Freedom Foundation has found.
The investigation, reported by Al Jazeera, found that Home Minister Amit Shah signed off on exemptions from make in India procurement rules, clearing at least 422 items of foreign technology for purchase by government forensic institutions, including products made by the Israeli firm Cellebrite.
The January waiver and the NIA purchase
The foundation reviewed a letter from the Ministry of Home Affairs dated January 7 in which Shah signed off on a wide-ranging, one-year waiver of make in India rules to clear a path for buying at least 422 forensic items.
Another letter dated January 20 showed Shah permitted the National Investigation Agency to buy Cellebrite's Premium Tool on a three-year licence for about Rs 50 million.
From the 422-item exemption list, the foundation identified 118 items under digital and multimedia forensics, including Cellebrite's Pathfinder, Inseyets On-Prem Pro and Inseyets Offline. Other products came from firms including Magnet, MSAB, Oxygen Forensics and Belkasoft.
An exemption does not confirm whether a particular product was purchased by any government agency. It points to the range of forensic capabilities that opened up for procurement by Indian agencies.
What the tools can do
In tender specifications reviewed as part of the investigation, the software sought must be capable of using login tokens recovered from seized phones or computers to access more than 100 cloud services. Login tokens are digital keys that keep users signed in to online accounts.
A Delhi Police bid for its National Cyber Forensic Laboratory sought software that bypasses passwords on Apple, Windows and Linux systems, recovers internet activity and deleted files, bypasses screen locks, performs full file system extractions and decrypts backups.
The police also sought an all-in-one system to access more than 100 cloud services, including Google, Apple, WhatsApp, Instagram, Telegram, Discord and dating platforms such as Tinder, using account credentials or login tokens recovered from devices.
A legal grey zone
The investigation found that India has no statute or protocol that specifically authorises or regulates the forced unlocking and full extraction of data from a mobile phone seized by law enforcement agencies.
Vrinda Bhandari, a Supreme Court lawyer who works on digital rights and privacy, said surveillance capabilities were becoming wider and deeper, and that it was now easier to conduct mass surveillance rather than targeted surveillance.
The report notes that Cellebrite's tools have been used against journalists and activists in countries including Serbia, Jordan, Kenya and Russia. States governed by opposition parties, including Himachal Pradesh, Keralam and Karnataka, also purchased similar phone-extraction tools, according to the investigation.
Al Jazeera said it reached out to the NIA, the Home Ministry and the home departments of the three opposition-ruled states for comment. None of them had responded by the time of publication.