In a significant development in the trial of Tathya Patel, accused of mowing down 11 people with a speeding Jaguar on ISKCON Bridge on July 20, 2023, five friends who were travelling in the car with him have turned hostile on one crucial aspect, the vehicle's speed.

Although they had earlier recorded their statements under Section 164 of the CrPC before a magistrate, the five witnesses told the court that they did not know the exact speed of the car. However, they stood by the other details of their earlier statements.

The testimonies of the five friends, who were travelling in the Jaguar at the time of the accident, were recorded in-camera before the Ahmedabad Rural Court. So far, 38 witnesses have completed their depositions and cross-examinations in the high-profile case involving Tathya Patel and his father, Pragnesh Patel.

They warned him to slow down, say witnesses

During the proceedings, public prosecutor Pravin Trivedi questioned the five friends about their earlier statements concerning the car's speed. The witnesses maintained that they were unaware of its exact speed.

However, they remained consistent on other details recorded before the magistrate, including the fact that they had warned Tathya to slow down, but he had ignored their advice. That part of their testimony has not changed.

The speed of the Jaguar is central to the prosecution's case, since the charge rests on the claim that the car was being driven at a dangerous speed when it struck people on the bridge. The five friends' refusal to confirm the speed weakens that part of the evidence, though their other statements remain on record.

Camera footage backs the prosecution

In contrast, an independent witness whose camera-mounted footage captured the entire incident gave a strong corroborative testimony in court. Pranshu Jitendra Ruparel told the court that he had witnessed the Jaguar crash and was involved in a scuffle with the young man pulled out of the driver's seat.

Ruparel also testified that the driver was addressing people at the scene as "Mom-Dad" before Tathya's father arrived and drove him away. He further confirmed that his bike-mounted camera had captured the crash.

He said he had handed over the footage to the police on a memory card and subsequently recorded a statement before a magistrate under Section 164 of the CrPC. The footage is expected to be a key piece of evidence as the trial continues.

Echoes of the Vismay Shah case

The development has drawn comparisons with the infamous 2013 Vismay Shah hit-and-run case, in which the court had directed action against star witness Lalit Gupta for turning hostile. While Vismay has completed his five-year prison sentence, proceedings against the hostile witness remain pending.

The comparison underlines how the conduct of witnesses can shape the outcome of high-profile crash trials, and how courts have in the past acted against witnesses who resile from their earlier statements.