With exactly a year to go before the 2027 Gujarat Assembly elections, the decade-old Patidar reservation agitation has resurfaced as a political flashpoint, with former activists divided over whether the movement contributed to the removal of then chief minister Anandiben Patel.
At a public gathering of the Patidar community in Jasdan, agitation leader Dinesh Bambhaniya expressed regret over the community losing a "good chief minister" like Anandiben Patel because of the agitation. He said the movement had secured several benefits for the community, including economic reservation, but its activists had also become a reason for her removal.
"I still feel bad that we became an excuse to remove Anandiben Patel. I want to meet her and apologise," Bambhaniya said. He added that the community had suffered because of her departure and should be careful not to repeat the mistake of seeking the removal of another chief minister.
Anandiben Patel served as Gujarat's first woman chief minister from 2014 and stepped down in August 2016, at the height of the Patidar agitation, which had begun in 2015 with a demand for reservation for the Patidar community. The circumstances of her departure have been debated ever since.
Her daughter responds warmly
Anandiben's daughter, Anar Patel, who was present at the Jasdan event, responded warmly, saying Bambhaniya had no reason to carry the regret. "My mother holds nothing against anyone. It is my responsibility to arrange a meeting between you and her soon," she said.
The exchange at Jasdan reopened old divisions among the leaders who spearheaded the agitation more than a decade ago, and the disagreement spilled into the open within hours.
However, Hardik Patel, a prominent face of the agitation who is now a BJP MLA, rejected Bambhaniya's assessment. He said the movement had neither forced anyone to resign nor been directed against any individual.
"The agitation was not launched to remove anyone or cause harm to anyone. It was for the welfare of the community. Bambhaniya's statement may reflect his personal views, but I have no regrets," Hardik Patel said.
Old warnings recalled
Sardar Patel Group leader Lalji Patel recalled how agitation leaders had opposed Anandiben as well as Patidar ministers Nitin Patel, Rajni Patel and Jitu Vaghani. He said he had repeatedly cautioned activists but was dismissed as a BJP supporter.
The remarks have reopened old divisions among the leaders who spearheaded the agitation. Several leaders who had once vowed never to enter politics have since joined either the BJP or the Congress, and the movement's legacy is now contested between its former leaders.
With the Assembly elections a year away, the question of who the agitation helped and who it hurt is set to feature in the political argument in Gujarat, where the Patidar community remains a significant electoral force.