Newly elected Bihar Legislative Council members Vanshidhar Brajwasi and Rahul Raj will keep their membership, after the Council Secretariat dismissed the disqualification petitions filed against them.
Deputy Secretary Manoj Kumar issued two separate official letters on the orders of the Acting Chairman, saying the petitions were not maintainable at the preliminary stage.
The letters said the petitions did not meet the mandatory conditions laid down in the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution and the Bihar Legislative Council Members (Disqualification on Ground of Defection) Rules, 1994.
Why the RJD petition was rejected
The RJD petition was filed by Abdul Bari Siddiqui, Dr Sunil Kumar Singh, Shashi Yadav, Rajiv Kumar and Afaq Ahmad. It sought action against Brajwasi, who was re-elected as an independent from the Tirhut Graduates constituency, and Rahul Raj, newly elected from the Saran Teachers constituency, on the ground of defection.
On review, the petition was rejected at the preliminary stage for violating Rules 6 and 7 of the 1994 Rules. The Secretariat said the petition was not prepared in the specified format laid down in Rule 7.
The required legal affidavit and annexures were also not attached in support of the petition, and the petition had not been verified as the rules require.
Five other petitioners also turned away
The Secretariat also declared invalid and dismissed the petitions of five other people. They include former MLA and Jan Suraaj core committee member Kishore Kumar of Saharsa, Sandeep Kumar of Madhubani, advocate Ramesh Kumar Singh Chandel of Vaishali, Rashtravadi Janlok Party (Satya) spokesperson Rupesh Kumar Kunwar of Muzaffarpur, and Vimohan Kumar of Muzaffarpur, a candidate in the Tirhut Graduates election of 2026.
Under Rule 6(1) of the 1994 Rules, only a sitting member of the Legislative Council can file a disqualification petition. Outsiders, including the Jan Suraaj petitioners, therefore had no legal standing to file, the Secretariat said.
Copies of the 1994 Rules have been sent to all the petitioners along with the letters, for clarity.
The defection row
Brajwasi and Rahul Raj had won the Legislative Council elections as independent candidates. Within days of their victory, both visited the BJP office in Patna, where photographs showed them wearing the party's gamchha and holding membership receipts.
The RJD and Jan Suraaj alleged that joining a party after being elected as independents violated the Tenth Schedule, the anti-defection law, and demanded that their membership be cancelled. The RJD submitted a memorandum to the Council Chairman on November 4, and Jan Suraaj filed its petition around the same time.
As the controversy grew, both leaders and the BJP clarified that they had not taken party membership, and had only extended support from outside.
The BJP state unit had also clarified that the two MLCs had only offered support, and had not formally joined the party.
Jan Suraaj had earlier said it would approach the High Court if no action was taken on its petition.