Police have detained a juvenile and arrested all 23 adults accused in the murder of 24-year-old Rohit Pathare in Vaijapur, even as Maharashtra Congress president Harshvardhan Sapkal on Monday demanded that a fresh SIT headed by an IPS officer take over the probe. All the accused have been remanded in police custody.
The demand for a new probe team came despite Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar Rural police completing arrests in the case within two weeks of Pathare's death.
Congress calls probe unsatisfactory
After meeting Pathare's family along with MP Kalyan Kale and district Congress chief Kiran Dongavkar, Sapkal termed the investigation unsatisfactory and sought inclusion of officers from outside Vaijapur and women officers in the team.
Comparing the killing to the murder of Massajog sarpanch Santosh Deshmukh, Sapkal blamed the state government for a breakdown in law and order. "There appears to be no effective police machinery left in the state, and criminals no longer fear police," he said.
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar Rural SP Prakash Jadhav said police were pushing for a strong prosecution. "We have sought a special public prosecutor to be appointed to contest the case, and we aim to file a foolproof chargesheet at the earliest," Jadhav said.
"Considering the seriousness of the crime, we constituted a special investigation team (SIT) to ensure a comprehensive, impartial and effective probe," he added.
The October 31 attack
According to the investigation, the murder was the culmination of a simmering dispute between members of the Shan-e-Maratha and Hindu Hriday Samrat Ganesh mandals dating back to the Ganesh festival.
On October 31, Pathare, who belonged to a backward community, was allegedly dragged out of his house by around 26 people and taken to a field in Rotegaon. His wife later alleged in her complaint that he was tied to a tree and assaulted with swords, iron rods and axes. His legs were allegedly crushed with stones and he was stabbed with a screwdriver. He succumbed to his injuries at a hospital in Shirdi on November 3.
There was a twist in the case even before Pathare's death. Around 1 am on November 1, Vaijapur police registered an FIR on a complaint by Krushna Jadhav against six named and several unidentified people under multiple BNS sections, including attempt to murder. Pathare himself was named as accused number 2 in that case.
After Pathare died, his wife lodged a separate complaint on November 4, leading to the registration of a murder case against 26 suspects for murder, rioting and unlawful assembly. "We are investigating the exact chronology of events for the past few months," a police officer said.
Protests after the killing
Pathare's death triggered widespread outrage in Vaijapur. Residents and relatives staged protests outside the police station, alleging delays in arrests after only one suspect was initially detained. His mother allegedly attempted immolation demanding immediate action against the accused, while protesters blocked the Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar-Nashik highway for nearly three hours.
The existing SIT, headed by additional SP Prashant Swami, is examining witness statements, technical evidence and the role of each accused. The team also includes Vaijapur SDPO Bhagwat Phunde, inspector Devidas Mupade, assistant inspectors Santosh Misale and Pradeep Bhivasane, and sub-inspector Manisha Jagtap.
With the incident fuelling caste tensions in the region, police have stepped up peace committee meetings and are monitoring social media to prevent provocative posts from escalating the situation.