The dispute inside Tata Trusts over the listing of Tata Sons deepened on Tuesday after former trustee Darius Khambata hit back at vice-chairmen Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh, accusing them of reversing their stand on a listing without explanation.
In a four-page letter dated November 17, Khambata said control of Tata Sons by Tata Trusts, which collectively own about two-thirds of the holding company, is the essence of the Tata model.
"My grievance is why you repeatedly voted to oppose listing but suddenly did a volte-face in April 2026," Khambata wrote, pointing out that the two vice-chairmen had supported the anti-listing stand of Tata Sons and Tata Trusts in March 2024, May 2025 and July 2025.
Khambata said their November 13 letter gave no reason for the change of mind, and argued that the merits or demerits of listing should be debated at a Trust meeting, not in correspondence or through the media.
RBI insists Tata Sons must list
The exchange came a day after the Reserve Bank of India wrote to Tata Sons on November 16, telling the company to comply with rules for upper-layer non-banking financial companies, including the mandatory listing requirement. The letter, addressed to chief financial officer Saurabh Agrawal, was in response to an October 6 letter from Tata Sons seeking guidance after its September 17 board meeting.
The RBI classified Tata Sons as an upper-layer NBFC in September 2022, setting a three-year deadline for listing. Tata Sons repaid its borrowings and applied in March 2024 to surrender its registration as a core investment company, but the regulator rejected the application in September 2026.
Tata Sons has assets of about Rs 2.01 lakh crore as of March 31, 2026. Tata Trusts hold a little over 66 per cent of the holding company, while the Shapoorji Pallonji Group holds around 18 per cent.
Chandrasekaran term and the November 26 meeting
Khambata also rejected allegations that he engineered a move to temporarily remove Srinivasan to alter the composition of the trusts, saying no such concerns were raised at trust meetings in 2024, 2025 or 2026. He left the trusts on November 9 after his term ended, having told chairman Noel Tata and chief executive Siddharth Sharma on November 2 that he would not seek reappointment.
He defended his position on N Chandrasekaran's third term as Tata Sons chairman, saying his November 2 letter concerned the way the Tata Sons board acted at its September 17 meeting, not Chandrasekaran's performance. The board voted on September 17 to reappoint Chandrasekaran for five years after his current term ends on February 20, 2027.
The confrontation comes ahead of the Tata Sons board meeting on November 26, where the listing question and a restructuring proposal mooted by Noel Tata are expected to be discussed. Jimmy Tata, the younger brother of late Ratan Tata, has backed a listing and the RBI's directive, directly challenging Noel Tata's position.