The Karnataka High Court has refused to quash criminal proceedings initiated by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) against two directors of Razorpay Private Limited over alleged lapses in merchant onboarding, KYC verification and transaction monitoring.

Justice M. Nagaprasanna held that the matter involved seriously disputed questions of fact that could only be decided at trial, and rejected the petition filed by Whole-Time Director Harshil Mathur and Managing Director Shashank Kumar as lacking merit. "At this stage of the proceedings, there is no warrant of interference in the light of the issue, as observed, being shrouded with seriously disputed questions of facts," the judge observed.

The directors and the allegations

Mathur and Kumar were arrayed as accused Nos. 8 and 9 in a complaint arising from an SFIO investigation into 33 companies.

The SFIO alleged lapses by the directors in KYC verification, due diligence and monitoring of transactions involving a digital lending platform accused of coercive loan recovery practices.

The SFIO submitted that Razorpay processed Rs 320 crore in transactions involving MENTPL, and the court noted the company's role as a conduit for transactions worth approximately Rs 320 crore.

The directors were implicated under Section 166 of the Companies Act, on the allegation that they failed to discharge their fiduciary duties in relation to the transactions involving MENTPL.

The directors disputed the SFIO's jurisdiction over Razorpay.

How the investigation began

The investigation followed a Registrar of Companies report alleging that JCIPL, a subsidiary of Fininty Private Limited, had created shell companies with dummy directors.

The Central Government ordered an SFIO probe on September 9, 2022.

One company under investigation, MENTPL, had entered into a lending services arrangement with NBFC X10 Financial Services. MENTPL allegedly used coercive loan recovery methods, generating wrongful gains of Rs 56.63 crore.

What the court said

"Whether such fiduciary duty is complied with by the petitioners or whether due-diligence is done by the petitioners or otherwise is a disputed question of fact, which can only be considered at the stage of trial," the court observed.

The court said it could not conduct a mini-trial to decide disputed questions of fact while considering a plea to quash the proceedings, and that the directors' arguments would have to be considered at a later stage.

The court noted that the proceedings were still at a nascent stage. Although Razorpay itself had not been made a party, its role could emerge if further investigation was conducted or the matter was taken forward.

The court observed that the petitioners would have to come out clean in a "full-blown trial".

Case details

The case is titled Mr. Harshil Mathur and Anr v. Union of India, Writ Petition No. 16078 of 2026.

Senior Advocate Sandesh J Chouta and Advocate Abhishek Kumar appeared for the petitioners. Advocates K Arvind Kamath, ASG, and Anuparna Bordoloi, CGC, appeared for the respondent.

Source: LiveLaw